With all of our justified slamming of all things emergent, post-evangelical, et. all, I was wondering, “Is there any place for mystery?” I believe that if we are being Biblical we need to leave a great deal of space for this.
Here is what I mean. I believe that what God has revealed about Himself, He has done so purposefully, so that we can understand Him. I think any plain reading of the Scriptures will render God as what most orthodox theologies say He is and what He does. There is no question that God is revealed in the pages of Scripture exactly how He wants us to know Him, and that the things we don’t know about Him are consistent with those we do know (this I will explain later.)
From this understanding, as we piece all of these elements of what we understand about God (both His character, makeup, and actions), we begin to categorize or systematize.
I have no problems with this. But I do believe that this is what “post-evangelicals” react against, when they speak of mystery. They take the post-modern rout which says, if we do not have all of truth, then we must admit, what we call truth (which is only partial) may not be truth at all. The “post-evangelical” takes this and tries to attach it to Christianity, saying in other words, “If God has not fully revealed Himself, then we may have systematized Him into something He is not, and therefore, we must look at all of Him or His Words as a ‘mystery’.”
I disagree with this use of the word mystery, because it betrays any fundamental understanding of anything. I may not have all the inner-workings of a plane figured out (trust me I don’t), but I still have no problem stepping on one and flying half way across the world.
It is not wrong for us to know that we have some things about God nailed down; not because of our cleverness or ingenuity, but because of what He has plainly revealed about Himself in His Word.
So you may be asking the question, “Where then does your idea of mystery come in, if at all?” I think the key verses in all of this discussion are found in Romans 11:33-36 (NASB 95).
33 Oh, the depth of the riches both of the wisdom and knowledge of God! How unsearchable are His judgments and unfathomable His ways! 34 For who has known the mind of the Lord, or who became His counselor? 35 Or who has first given to Him that it might be paid back to him again? 36 For from Him and through Him and to Him are all things. To Him be the glory forever. Amen.
First of all Paul is not saying that we can’t know anything about God. Paul has just finished describing God’s sovereignty over the salvation of men and God’s unbroken covenant plan for Israel. What Paul is saying; however, is that after all of this explanation, (which by the way God is inspiring him to write, thus, God is revealing Himself not only to Paul, but to all of us as well) there are just aspects we are not able to figure out. There are questions that will go unanswered and we should not question God, but rather thank Him for what He has revealed to us about Himself! This is the mystery of God. It is what He has not revealed about Himself, that we will spend all eternity getting to know.
I think in our justified reaction against all things “post-evangelical” we do not want to discount “mystery”, but embrace the fact that God has not revealed all to us, while at the same time upholding the truth, learning and teaching and worshiping the God who has revealed what He has.

